Economical, On-Demand GRCop Alloy Production

Materials and Coatings
Economical, On-Demand GRCop Alloy Production (LEW-TOPS-175)
In-Situ Alloyed, Additively Manufactured GRCop
Overview
Researchers at NASA Glenn Research Center have developed a new method to make high-performance GRCop alloys. This technology enables in-situ alloying of GRCop, a copper-chromium-niobium alloy, during additive manufacturing using only elemental metal powders instead of expensive pre-alloyed powders. The key advancement leverages the laser melting process step to react chromium and niobium directly within the pure copper matrix to form the Cr2Nb strengthening precipitate. This in situ processing enables significant advantages over conventional gas atomization methods including on-demand production, lower manufacturing costs, shorter lead times, and less impurity contamination. This innovative approach unlocks new design freedoms and alloy compositional flexibility for this high-performance copper alloy. The images above show that the new, patented, alloying process (in situ alloying of GRCop) produces strengthening phases (in left image) similar in size and shape to the conventional process of gas atomization of GRCop (on the right). The similarity suggests that NASA's new alloying process has the potential to perform as well as the conventional method that NASA has used to produce additively manufactured GRCop hardware.

The Technology
In-situ alloyed, additively manufactured GRCop components are produced by mixing elemental copper, chromium, and niobium powders and then selectively laser melting the powder mixture using powder bed fusion additive manufacturing. During laser melting, the chromium and niobium powders react to form Cr2Nb precipitates in the molten state, which are then dispersed in the pure copper matrix upon solidification. This dispersed precipitate phase is encapsulated within the pure copper matrix upon solidification, resulting in the characteristic microstructure of GRCop alloys with high thermal conductivity from the copper combined with superior mechanical properties from the precipitates. Optimization of process parameters like laser power has enabled up to 89% conversion of the constituent elements into Cr2Nb precipitates. The achieved rapid cooling rates of ~10^4-10^6 K/s enable formation of fine Cr2Nb precipitates around 0.1-1 micrometers in size. The technology is currently at a TRL 4, and NASA has developed and tested coupons of material using the new process. The related patent is now available to license. Please note that NASA does not manufacturer products itself for commercial sale.
Image provided by inventor David Scannopeico from published document, 
https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20230003305/downloads/2023-02-ISGRCopPresentation.pdf This image shows the +99.8% dense material additively manufactured using the new method. Its hardness is similar to that of traditionally processed GRCop alloys.
Benefits
  • Higher thermal conductivity: The nearly pure copper matrix provides higher thermal conductivity than conventionally produced GRCop.
  • Excellent high temperature mechanical properties
  • Faster production: Eliminates the lengthy gas atomization process for pre-alloying, reducing lead times from roughly 16 weeks to days.
  • Lower cost: Uses lower cost elemental powders rather than expensive pre-alloyed powders.
  • Flexible compositions: Adjust elemental powder ratios to produce custom GRCop alloy chemistries.

Applications
  • Aerospace: Combustion chambers and nozzle liners for liquid rocket engines
  • Marine: Water penetration barriers
  • Automotive: Engine components for high temperature service.
  • Propulsion: High heat flux components like fuel injector faces.
  • Power Generation: Heat exchangers and piping for concentrating solar power systems.
Technology Details

Materials and Coatings
LEW-TOPS-175
LEW-19909-1
11,859,272
Similar Results
Laser powder bed fusion manufactured tensile rods for tensile testing of GRC103y. Credit: NASA
GRC103y: Nano-Yttria Strengthened C103 for Additive Manufacturing
The manufacturing process, building on techniques showcased in LEW-TOPS-151, employs a novel acoustic mixing technique to coat spherical C103 powder particles with a uniform distribution of sub-200 nanometer yttria particles. During laser powder bed fusion additive manufacturing, layer-by-layer remelting disperses these yttria particles uniformly throughout the component microstructure. This eliminates the expensive, time-consuming mechanical alloying steps traditionally required for ODS alloys while enabling near-net-shape fabrication of complex geometries. Performance testing demonstrates substantial improvements: GRC103y exhibits double the yield strength at 800°C and 1.5x the yield strength at 1,400°C compared to baseline C103. The alloy also shows superior thermal stability: after one hour at 1,500°C, GRC103y retains 90% of its room temperature strength compared to only 67% for C103. Preliminary creep testing at 1,300°C and a stress of 50 MPa indicates significant improvements in creep resistance by 2539 times over baseline C103. Furthermore, GRC103y maintains excellent formability, allowing manufacturers to use traditional fabrication methods when desired. While NASA originally developed GRC103y for rocket propulsion and hypersonic vehicle applications, the alloy offers value across multiple industries. Aerospace companies can achieve weight savings or push systems to higher temperatures, while the alloy's compatibility with commercial oxidation coatings makes it suitable for environments requiring oxidation protection. GRC103y is currently available for patent licensing.
High-Temperature Ni-Based Superalloy Composition
NASA's new Ni-based superalloy uses a powder metallurgy (PM) composition that inhibits the deleterious gamma-prime to gamma-phase transformation along stacking faults during high temperature creep deformation. Ni-base superalloys have excellent high temperature properties, mostly due to the presence of coherent precipitates. At higher temperatures, these precipitates are defeated by the diffusional shear dislocations producing intrinsic and extrinsic faults. Recent studies have found that, during deformation of turbine disk alloys at high temperature, Co, Cr, and Mo segregate to these faults (removing Ni and Al) inside the strengthening precipitates of these alloys. This represents a local phase transformation from the strengthening precipitate to the weaker matrix phase. Therefore, this elemental segregation significantly weakens the ability of a precipitate to withstand further deformation, producing faster strain rates in the alloy at higher temperatures. This invention presents a solution to prevent this type of segregation along these two faults to improve the creep properties of turbine disks and similar Ni-based alloys. By alloying a specific amount of eta phase formers (Ti, Ta, Nb, and Hf), the phase transformation to can be eliminated along 2-layer extrinsic stacking faults (SESFs) in precipitates without precipitating bulk eta phase. Also, by adding a certain amount of D019 formers (Mo and W), the phase transformation to can be mitigated along 1-layer intrinsic stacking faults (SISFs) without producing bulk sigma phase. This alloy composition incorporates both strengthening methods for use in jet turbine disks, though the composition has applications in other high-stress and/or high-temperature environments as are found in power plants, space launch systems, and other critical structural applications.
Gore panels are welded together to form the dome ends of cryogenic tanks.
Improving Formability of Al-Li Alloys
Via this NASA innovation, a product is first heated to a temperature within the range of 204 to 343 degrees C for an extended soak of up to 16 hours. The product is then slowly heated to a second temperature within the range of 371 to 482 degrees C for a second soak of up to 12 hours. Finally, the product is slowly cooled to a final soak temperature of 204 to 343 degrees C before cooling to room temperature. The product so treated will exhibit greatly improved formability. To date, the low formability issue has limited the use of lightweight Al-Li alloys for large rocket fuel tank dome applications. Manufacturing a dome by stretch forming typically requires multiple panels as well as multiple welding and inspection steps to assemble these panels into a full-scale fuel tank dome. Complex tensile and bending stresses induced during the stretch forming operations of Al-Li alloys have resulted in high rates of failure for this process. To spin form a large rocket dome, the spin blank must be prepared by joining smaller plates together using friction stir welding. However, friction stir welding produces a distinct metallurgical structure inside and around the friction stir weld that makes it very susceptible to cracking during spin forming.
Predicting Defects in Additive Manufacturing
This method leverages advanced computational modeling to evaluate localized heating conditions and fusion metrics and quantify defect risks dynamically, allowing for optimized build files and process adjustments that drastically improve the final component. The model can be trained using PPF and print samples from an AM machine's prior builds to learn correlations between the machine's instructions, behavior during build, and final product quality. By integrating machine feedback metrics, model-based thermal and fusion metrics, and in-situ sensor metrics, the model learns predictive signatures that allow it to quantify localized defect probability in PBF laser beam metals. Manufacturers can employ this method to understand the reproducibility of their prints and perform defect compensation before parts are fully deployed, improving quality, reliability, and success. Particularly useful to industries that require stringent certification of safety-critical components, such as the aerospace, space, medical, and automotive sectors, this method can be flexibly deployed globally or adapted to specific AM machines. By predicting the probability of defects before and during production, 3D printing service providers and AM equipment manufacturers can save significant amounts of time and money while drastically reducing part variability. This predictive capability also allows organizations to certify parts faster and ensure consistent material properties, which is essential for meeting rigorous performance and safety standards. This is method is currently available for patent licensing (no software included).
Testing of L-PBF GRCop-42 Chamber. This chamber was manufactured with advanced additively manufactured alloys through laser powder bed fusion. The purpose of this was to test the new alloy in a harsh environment. Source: NASA Presentation
Dispersion Enhanced Aluminum Alloys for Additive Manufacturing Applications
Dispersion Enhanced Aluminum Alloys improve the additive manufacturing performance of high-strength aluminum alloys by modifying the alloy powder with uniformly dispersed nano-sized ceramic particles. Building on the dispersion and acoustic mixing methods developed during the creation of NASA Glenn's GRX-810 technology, researchers use an acoustic field to attach nanoscale alumina dispersoids to the surface of each aluminum alloy powder particle. During mixing, acoustic energy creates rapid micro-vibrations that cause the alumina particles to collide with the metal powder, embed against its surface, and distribute into a uniform shell that surrounds each particle. This produces a composite powder in which every aluminum particle carries its own evenly spaced ceramic nucleation sites. When the composite powder is delivered into an additive manufacturing process such as laser powder bed fusion or directed energy deposition, the aluminum alloy melts while the alumina dispersoids remain solid due to their significantly higher melting temperature. As the molten pool flows and mixes, the dispersoids remain suspended throughout the liquid region. During solidification, these solid particles interrupt grain growth and serve as nucleation points that promote the formation of fine equiaxed grains. This refined microstructure distributes thermal stresses more uniformly and disrupts the crack initiation mechanisms that typically occur in high-strength alloys like AA 2050. By stabilizing the alloy during solidification, the technology enables these advanced materials to be printed with greater reliability, improved geometric control, and more consistent mechanical behavior across the final product. The enhanced alloy technology is available for patent licensing.
Stay up to date, follow NASA's Technology Transfer Program on:
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
Facebook Logo X Logo Linkedin Logo Youtube Logo