HYPERFIRE
propulsion
HYPERFIRE (SSC-TOPS-12)
HYdrocarbon Propellants Enabling Reproduction of Flows in Rocket Engines
Overview
The two main sub-scale, ground-based rocket aerodynamics testing techniques hot-fire testing and cold-flow testing pose a series of tradeoffs. Hot-fire testing is generally much more accurate, but is often burdensome, costly, and requires long lead times due to design work, infrastructure preparation, etc. Cold-flow testing is much less expensive and has a rapid turnaround time, but conventional simulants (e.g., nitrogen, steam) used in cold-flow testing yield less accurate results (i.e., results that are not sufficiently representative of test article performance).
While researching methods to optimize such tradeoffs, engineers at NASAs Stennis Space Center discovered that ethane can be tuned to approximate rocket exhaust plumes generated by several common rocket propellants. This led NASA to develop the HYdrocarbon Propellants Enabling Reproduction of Flows in Rocket Engines (HYPERFIRE), a sub-scale, non-reacting flow test system. HYPERFIRE uses heated ethane to enable physical simulation of rocket engines powered by a broad range of propellants in an inexpensive, accurate, and simple fashion.
The Technology
In order to maintain the low cost, simplicity, and quick turnaround of cold-flow testing while improving accuracy, NASA evaluated unconventional gases for use as simulants. During such evaluations, NASA discovered that by adjusting stagnation temperature, the isentropic exponent of ethane can be tuned to approximate those of common rocket propellants (e.g., hydrogen, hypergols, alcohols, and hydrocarbons). Furthermore, due to ethanes high auto-ignition temperature and resistance to condensation, tuned ethane enables testing of expansion ratios much larger than conventional inert-gas testing.
To leverage this discovery, NASA developed a hardware-based system to treat ethane and obtain nozzle chamber conditions that match the appropriate aerodynamics for a specific test. The system, named HYPERFIRE, works in the following manner. Liquid ethane is transferred to a piston-style run tank, where it is pressurized. Then, the ethane is run through two insulated pebble beds where it is heated, vaporized, and stabilized. Finally, the treated ethane is transferred from the second pebble bed to a small thrust takeout structure, and through the test article. Control of valves and regulators is managed by an onboard computer, accessed via a LabVIEW™ interface. The system is mounted on a hurricane-resistant steel frame to enable transportation via forklift.
Heated ethane reproduces the aerodynamics of combustion products at low temperatures relative to alternative testing methods. Thus, test articles can be manufactured using low-cost, low temperature rated, transparent materials (e.g., acrylic). In addition to reducing testing cost, this grants optical access to internal flowfields, enabling advanced diagnostic techniques (e.g., Schlieren imaging, particle image velocimetry) not possible with hot-fire testing and less meaningful with conventional cold-flow testing.
Benefits
- Vastly reduces testing cost and timeline: NASAs HYPERFIRE enables the end-to-end (i.e., design, fabrication, and testing) rocket aerodynamics testing process to be performed in roughly one month (~90% schedule reduction relative to hot-fire testing), and at low-cost (~98% reduced cost relative to using hot-fire testing).
- Portable & self-contained: The HYPERFIRE is portable, self-contained, and includes integrated control and data acquisition. It can be moved via forklift and shipped to a testing location. It plugs into a wall power outlet and requires no external components.
- Improves testing accuracy: Heated ethane generated and flowed through test articles by NASAs HYPERFIRE is more effective than traditional simulants (e.g., nitrogen, steam) used in cold-flow testing thus, results using the system are more representative of the aerodynamics of the test article than conventional cold-flow testing. Error rates for the 14 tests run to date using the HYPERFIRE have been on the order of ~2% cumulatively for steady state operation, and ~5% for transient development of the plume structure.
Applications
- Rocket engine testing & development
- Fundamental nozzle research
- Simulation of combustion products (e.g., automotive testing)
Technology Details
propulsion
SSC-TOPS-12
SSC-00598
SSC-00561
"Physical Simulation of Rocket Exhaust Aerodynamics Using Heated Ethane: Conceptual Foundations," Daniel R. Jones, June 2019, https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20190030272
"Physical Simulation of Rocket Exhaust Aerodynamics Using Heated Ethane: Prototypical Experiments," Daniel R. Jones, October 2020, https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20205009122
"Physical Simulation of Rocket Exhaust Aerodynamics Using Heated Ethane: Prototypical Experiments," Daniel R. Jones, October 2020, https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20205009122
Tags:
|
|
Related Links:
|
Similar Results
Calculation of Unsteady Aerodynamic Loads Using Fast-Response Pressure-Sensitive Paint (PSP)
Traditionally, unsteady pressure transducers have been the instrumentation of choice for investigating unsteady flow phenomena which can be time-consuming and expensive. The ability to measure and compute these flows has been a long-term challenge for aerospace vehicle designers and manufacturers. Results using only the pressure transducers are prone to inaccuracies, providing overly conservative load predictions in some cases and underestimating load predictions in other areas depending on the flow characteristics. NASA Ames has developed a new state-of-the-art method for measuring fluctuating aerodynamic-induced pressures on wind tunnel models using unsteady Pressure Sensitive Paint (uPSP). The technology couples recent advances in high-speed cameras, high-powered energy sources, and fast response pressure-sensitive paint. The unsteady pressure-sensitive paint (uPSP) technique has emerged as a powerful tool to measure flow, enabling time-resolved measurements of unsteady pressure fluctuations within a dense grid of spatial points on a wind tunnel model. The invention includes details surrounding uPSP processing. This technique enables time-resolved measurements of unsteady pressure fluctuations within a dense grid of spatial points representing the wind tunnel model. Since uPSP is applied by a spray gun, it is continuously distributed. With this approach, if the model geometry can be painted, viewed from a camera, and excited by a lamp source, uPSP data can be collected. Unsteady PSP (uPSP) has the ability to determine more accurate integrated unsteady loads.
Macroflash (Cup Cryostat)
Advances in new polymers and composites along with growing industrial needs in below-ambient temperature applications have brought about the Macroflash development. Accurate thermal performance information, including effective thermal conductivity data, are needed under relevant end-use conditions. The Macroflash is a practical tool for basic testing of common materials or research evaluation of advanced materials/systems.
The Macroflash can test solids, foams, or powders that are homogeneous or layered in composition. Test specimens are typically 75mm in diameter and 6mm in thickness. The cold side is maintained by liquid nitrogen at 77 K while a heater disk maintains a steady warm-side temperature from ambient up to 373 K. The steady boiloff of the liquid nitrogen provides a direct measure of the heat energy transferred through the thickness of the test specimen. Nitrogen or other gas is supplied to the instrument to establish a stable, moisture-free, ambient pressure environment. Different compression loading levels can also be conveniently applied to the test specimen as needed for accurate, field-representative thermal performance data. The Macroflash is calibrated from approximately 10 mW/m-K to 800 mW/m-K using well-characterized materials.
Cryostat-100
Cryostat-100 combines the best features of previous cryostats developed by NASA, while offering new features and conveniences. This unit can readily handle the full range of cryogenic-vacuum conditions over several orders of magnitude of heat flux. Guide rings, handling tools, and other design items make insulation change-out and test measurement verification highly reliable and efficient to operate. The new apparatus requires less ancillary equipment (it is not connected to storage tank, phase separator, subcooler, etc.) to operate properly. It is top-loading, which makes disassembly, change-out, and instrumentation hook-up much faster. The thermal stability is improved because of internal vapor plates, a single-tube system of filling and venting, bellows feed-throughs, Kevlar thread suspensions, and heavy-wall stainless-steel construction.
The cold mass of Cryostat-100 is 1m long, with a diameter of 168 mm. The test articles can therefore be of a corresponding length and diameter, with a nominal thickness of 25.4 mm. Shorter lengths are acceptable, and thicknesses may be from 0 mm to 50 mm. Tests are conducted from ambient pressure (760 torr) to high vacuum (below 110-4 torr) and at any vacuum pressure increment between these two extremes. The residual gas (and purge gas) is typically nitrogen but can be any purge gas, such as helium, argon, or carbon dioxide.
Typically, eight cold vacuum pressures are performed for each test series. The warm boundary temperature is approximately 293 K, and the cold boundary temperature is approximately 78 K. The delta temperature for the cryogenic testing is therefore approximately 215 K. A unique lift mechanism provides for change-out of the insulation test specimens. It also provides for maintenance and other operations in the most effective and time-efficient ways. The lift mechanism is also a key to the modularity of the overall system.
Cryostat-500
The Cryostat-500 provides laboratory measurement of the steady-state thermal transmission properties of thermal insulation systems under conditions below ambient temperature. Liquid nitrogen is used as a direct measure of the energy going through the test specimen. Thermal insulation systems may be composed of one or more materials that may be homogeneous or non-homogeneous at boundary conditions from 77 K to 373 K and in environments from high vacuum (10E-7 torr) to ambient pressure (10E+3 torr).
The Cryostat-500 provides a much wider range of thermal performance and covers the full range of environmental conditions for applications below ambient temperature. The instrument has been proven through extensive testing of foams, composite panels, multilayer insulation (MLI) systems, aerogel blankets, fiberglass, and many other types of materials. Both the quality and quantity of the thermal performance data for insulation materials and systems have increased even as the process and method has become more time efficient and cost effective. Further guidelines on the test method and equipment for the Cryostat-500 are given in ASTM C1774, Annex A3.
Cladding and Freeform Deposition for Coolant Channel Closeout
LWDC technology enables an improved channel wall nozzle with an outer liner that is fused to the inner liner to contain the coolant. It is an additive manufacturing technology that builds upon large-scale cladding techniques that have been used for many years in the oil and gas industry and in the repair industry for aerospace components. LWDC leverages wire freeform laser deposition to create features in place and to seal the coolant channels. It enables bimetallic components such as an internal copper liner with a superalloy jacket. LWDC begins when a fabricated liner made from one material, Material #1, is cladded with an interim Material #2 that sets up the base structure for channel slotting. A robotic and wire-based fused additive welding system creates a freeform shell on the outside of the liner. Building up from the base, the rotating weld head spools a bead of wire, closing out the coolant channels as the laser traverses circumferentially around the slotted liner. This creates a joint at the interface of the two materials that is reliable and repeatable. The LWDC wire and laser process is continued for each layer until the slotted liner is fully closed out without the need for any filler internal to the coolant channels. The micrograph on the left shows the quality of the bond at the interface of the channel edge and the closeout layer; on the right is a copper channel closed out with stainless.