Cost-Effective DC Source Emulator for Microgrid Testing
Power Generation and Storage
Cost-Effective DC Source Emulator for Microgrid Testing (LEW-TOPS-189)
Impedance-based methodology enables rapid verification of DC power systems using commercial equipment and custom filtering
Overview
Testing complex DC microgrid systems traditionally requires recreating entire power architectures with actual hardware copies, a process that can take months or years and cost millions of dollars. This is especially challenging in aerospace applications where specialty components are expensive, scarce, or still under development. Researchers at NASA’s Glenn Research Center have developed a practical methodology that enables engineers to emulate DC power sources using commercially available dynamic power supplies combined with custom-designed filters and external controllers. This hardware-in-the-loop approach uses impedance matching and external control circuits to replicate the electrical characteristics of any DC power source without requiring the actual hardware. By measuring or simulating the impedance of a target power source, engineers can design equivalent filter networks and tune controller gains to make standard lab equipment behave identically to specialized systems.
This technique has been validated to TRL 7 and is actively used to define power supply requirements and specifications for NASA's Gateway lunar outpost program. The methodology reduces verification testing from millions of dollars and months of effort down to tens of thousands of dollars and weeks of timeline, enabling rapid iteration and troubleshooting without risking expensive flight hardware.
The Technology
The DC Source Emulator methodology combines impedance characterization, custom filter design, and external control implementation to replicate any DC power source using standard laboratory equipment. Engineers first identify the system requiring verification and determine the impedance characteristics of the power source at the interface through hardware testing, simulation, or circuit analysis. Using this impedance data, they design a filter network that matches the target characteristics as seen from the interface.
This custom filter connects to the output of a commercially available dynamic DC power supply or linear amplifier. External voltage and current sensing circuits work with external controllers to command the power supply output to respond identically to the physical hardware being emulated. The supply must be capable of changing its output voltage and current in response to external inputs. Transient load step response, impedance response, and ripple characteristics can all be verified to match the target system. Controllers such as PI or PID configurations command the supply output, capturing small signal response for minor variations and transient response for sudden changes. An optional ripple injection stage using an amplifier can be added for increased emulation accuracy.
Once configured, the emulated system can be tested for stability across all loading conditions without requiring actual power source hardware. The methodology shapes impedance on a target impedance plot while using high-bandwidth power supplies in either current or voltage mode. The same equipment can be dynamically reconfigured for different emulation targets by changing the output filter and controller parameters, making it highly adaptable across various DC power architectures including converters, batteries, fuel cells, and complex multi-source systems. The DC Source Emulator is available for patent licensing.
Benefits
- Dramatic Cost Reduction: Reduces verification testing costs from millions of dollars down to tens of thousands by eliminating the need for expensive hardware copies or custom emulators.
- Uses Standard Equipment: Built with commercially available dynamic DC power supplies and linear amplifiers, making it accessible without specialized procurement.
- Accelerated Testing Timelines: Compresses verification testing from months or years down to weeks, enabling faster system development and integration.
- Scalable Application: Applicable across system sizes from small lab-scale testing to full-scale operational environments in space, air, ground, and marine systems.
- Versatile Configuration: Can emulate any DC power source including converters, batteries, fuel cells, generator-rectifiers, and complex multi-source systems with simple reconfiguration.
Applications
- Aerospace Power Systems: Enables verification testing of spacecraft and aircraft DC power distribution systems without requiring actual flight hardware.
- Electric Vehicle Development: Provides cost-effective testing of DC microgrid architectures for electrified aircraft, marine vessels, and ground vehicles during development phases.
- Renewable Energy Integration: Facilitates testing of solar, battery, and fuel cell integration into DC microgrids for both terrestrial and space applications.
- Standards Development: Allows agencies and industry consortia to develop power quality standards and interface specifications before hardware becomes widely available.
Technology Details
Power Generation and Storage
LEW-TOPS-189
LEW-20460-1
Patent Pending
|
Tags:
|
|
|
Related Links:
|
Similar Results
Enhanced DC Bus Emulator
Combining a dynamic load emulation technique with a PWM dithering technique, NASA’s technology provides a more efficient, cost-effective, and practical method to emulate complex loads. While there are commercially available electronic device loads on the market that meet basic emulation needs, these devices are limited; they are limited with respect to small input voltage changes, and to feedback signals from the device’s power system, which may lack the strength and resolution needed to emulate accurately.
A common solution for the bus emulation limitation is to construct a model of an actual microgrid using representative loads and connections. But this can be complex, costly, and have limitations in performance. NASA’s approach addresses these challenges without creating an actual model microgrid to replicate the systems.
As opposed to stand-alone COTS electronic load devices or model microgrids using representative loads and connections for a given test, NASA’s technology is a system constructed of an input power filter, a COTS electronic load device or load subsystem, and a power control circuit. The input power filter is designed to emulate load or bus performance at the medium to high frequency range. The power control circuit combined with the electronic load or load subsystem emulates lower frequency and constant power dynamics of the system. Lastly, the power control circuit linearizes digitization and quantization issues present with digitally controlled COTS electronic loads.
The power control circuit can be set to measure a load voltage, which is divided by a determined value for power, and combined with a triangle wave dither (the power control circuit block image demonstrates how to integrate a triangle wave dither). This dither dynamically adjusts the electrical current or power to keep it constant within the commercially purchased load device, enabling accurate emulation of complex DC microgrid systems.
Fuel Cell Power Management
In general, individual fuel cells produce relatively small electrical potentials, so fuel cells are "stacked" or placed in series (anode to cathode) to increase the combined voltage and meet the application's requirements. The current is drawn off by connection points, which typically are at the extreme ends of the fuel cell stack. DC power converters reduce or boost the voltage produced at the ends of the stack into a voltage that can be used by an attached device. However, these converters add cost, mass, volume, and potential failure points into the fuel cell system.
With NASA Glenn's groundbreaking technique, the fuel cell stack includes a plurality of connection points to the device instead of having a fixed number of individual fuel cells. By connecting additional cells in the same stack to the device, the system power can be to be tailored to produce the required voltage for the connected device. Initially, this plurality includes a ground, a first connection point, and a second connection point. Additional connection points to the device can be added as needed, resulting in various powers that are available for use. Each connection point allows power to be drawn from the combined voltages of the fuel cells located between the connection point and the ground. This configuration permits the voltage to be adjusted to the system power requirements of the device without the need to add DC power converters to the fuel cell system to add additional fuel cell systems to meet the power demand of the device. For larger fuel cell configurations in particular, NASA's innovative technique results in a far less costly, more efficient means of power generation.
Self-Bootstrapping Isolated Power Converter
NASA’s Self-Bootstrapping IPC operates in either transition mode for bootstrapping or fixed frequency mode for a regulated output via closed feedback. The transition mode is initially turned on via the input (i.e., primary) voltage control of the main switch and acts as a bootstrap converter utilizing a Gallium Nitrate transistor to control peak primary inductor current. That peak current can be varied via the sensor gain and/or a precise artificially generated offset and controls the switching frequency together with the secondary load (i.e., output). The IPC operates in transition mode until the Pulse Width Modulator (PWM) Under Voltage Lockout threshold is reached and fixed frequency mode begins. Fixed frequency operation is controlled by the PWM and the normal operation mode of the converter maintains a frequency while varying the duty cycle as needed. The PWM is secondary ground referenced and controls primary switching via galvanic isolation. The peak current in transition mode is set higher than the peak current in fixed frequency operation to prevent interruption or instability while in fixed frequency operation after bootstrap is completed. However, the transition mode control can serve as the overall peak current limiter. This invention is applicable to both flyback and buck-derived topologies with similar efficiency and size advantages.
While NASA originally developed the Self-Bootstrapping IPC for CubeSats and space-based electronics with strict SWaP requirements, it may also be useful for safety-critical industries (e.g., aerospace and defense) to allow for high reliability power supplies and more favorable SWaP than existing state-of-the-art high-power dc-dc converters. The reliability, efficiency, and SWaP advantages of this NASA invention could also benefit medium- and high-power commercial power supplies.
Universal Power Converter for a Lunar Power Grid
NASA’s Universal Modular Interface Converter (UMIC) is a bidirectional, modular power electronics converter that transfers power between a 120 V DC space power bus, and a medium-to-high-voltage, three-phase AC power grid. The UMIC system contains multiple parallel AC/DC UMIC modules that convert between 120 V DC and low voltage AC, as well as one or more transformers that convert power from the low voltage AC bus to the grid voltage. The UMIC module consists of multiple subsystems, including the power stage, gate driver, Field Programmable Gate Array (FPGA)-based controller, output filter, signal conditioning and sensing circuits, and thermal management subsystems. An FPGA-based controller is included within each AC/DC module and is used to regulate desired power system variables; synchronize power switching events and share load current between modules; synchronize the modules with existing service on the grid; receive commands; and share telemetry. The FPGA-based controller subsystem includes the FPGA Integrated Circuit, associated flash memory, and a controller area network (CAN) transceiver.
It is envisioned that future UMIC designs can support lunar grid expansions, a Mars surface grid, or large space stations. These applications may necessitate different grid voltages or frequencies, or different control logic and communication systems. However, the core UMIC architecture and functionality will remain the same.
The related patent is now available to license. Please note that NASA does not manufacture products itself for commercial sale.
Residual Mode Filters
Many control problems can benefit from the adaptive control algorithm described. This algorithm is well-suited to nonlinear applications that have unknown modeling parameters and poorly known operating conditions. Disturbance accommodation is a critical component of many systems. By using feedback control with disturbance accommodation, system performance and reliability can be increased considerably. Often the form of the disturbance is known, but the amplitude is unknown. For instance, a motor operating on a structure used for accurate pointing would cause a sinusoidal disturbance of a known frequency content. The algorithm described is able to accurately cancel these disturbances, without needing knowledge of their amplitude. In markets needing controllers, the efficiency, uptime, and lifespan of equipment can be dramatically increased due to the robustness of this technologys design.



