Optimized Airfoil Design for Aerial Flight Vehicles in Low-Reynolds Flight

Aerospace
Optimized Airfoil Design for Aerial Flight Vehicles in Low-Reynolds Flight (TOP2-333)
System and Method for Developing Optimal Airfoil and Rotor Sets for High Subsonic/Low Supersonic, Low-Reynolds-Number Conditions (ELISA/ROAMX)
Overview
The success of the Mars Helicopter Ingenuity has inspired efforts to improve fundamental understanding of compressible, low Reynolds number aerodynamics and wing/rotor performance, especially in atmospheres of very low densities. Studies have focused on optimizing unconventional airfoils, revealing significant possible advancements in sectional aerodynamic airfoil performance. Ames Research Center has developed a technology that relates generally to multi-objective optimization and, more particularly, to methods and systems for producing efficient airfoil geometries for use in aerial flight vehicles in low Reynolds conditions. The invention, developed under the Rotor Optimization for the Advancement of Mars eXploration (ROAMX) project, provides a method for optimizing airfoil geometries for aerial flight vehicles in general, and also supports airfoil geometries specifically for operating in Martian or other Low Reynolds number environments.

The Technology
This invention, developed under the Rotor Optimization for the Advancement of Mars eXploration (ROAMX) project, provides a method for optimizing airfoil geometries for aerial flight vehicles generally, and can also specifically optimize airfoil geometries for operating in Martian or other low Reynolds number environments. The method introduces a new “ROAMX parameterization” that defines geometric constraints, such as camber node count and the number and order of Bézier curve segments, to generate candidate airfoil shapes. A genetic algorithm evaluates these shapes against multiple objectives and iteratively selects the best-performing designs, converging on a Pareto-optimal front. This enables simultaneous optimization of metrics such as maximizing lift and minimizing drag. Using the ROAMX 1301 parameterization, the method produced an airfoil with lift to drag ratio improvements of up to 42% over the outboard airfoil used on the Mars Helicopter Ingenuity, representing a significant performance gain.
ROAMX test stand used to validate rotor performance Top: The roamx-1301 airfoil with flow features: (A) separation, (B) free shear layer, (C) large scale vortices, and (D) no time accurate attached flow.
Bottom: ROAMX-optimized airfoils will significantly improve the flight ranges of the Mars Ingenuity Helicopter.
Benefits
  • Generates highly efficient low Reynolds number airfoils that improve rotor performance and extend flight endurance.
  • Reduces design and CFD workflow time by up to 10× through fast, parallelized airfoil wing/rotor optimization for streamlined and rapid prototyping.
  • Enables flexible and unconventional airfoil shaping via ROAMX parameterization with tunable camber, thickness, and curve orders.
  • Supports lightweight, low cost blade manufacturing through simple but high performance airfoil geometries.
  • Extends UAV flight time by maximizing lift to drag performance at low Reynolds numbers.
  • Offers seamless compatibility with widely used airfoil and rotor analysis tools, from low to high fidelity codes.
  • Provides an easy to use workflow requiring minimal training, enabling non experts to perform advanced rotorcraft airfoil design.

Applications
  • Small-scale Earth-based rotorcraft (MAVs, UAVs)
  • Endurance-focused rotor UAVs
  • Mars aerial flight vehicles
  • Rotary-Wing UAVs & MAVs
  • Micro Aerial Vehicles (MAVs) & Small Rotary Drones
  • Commercial Fixed-Wing UAVs (Hybrid or Multi Rotor)
  • eVTOL & VTOL Rotorcraft
  • Small Helicopters & Commercial Drone Blades
  • The energy industry could leverage the software to assist with design of more efficient wind turbine blades
  • Developers of aerodynamic design software used for mid-fidelity and high-fidelity design, modeling, and simulation
Technology Details

Aerospace
TOP2-333
ARC-19074-1
Patent Pending
https://rotorcraft.arc.nasa.gov/Publications/files/MarsHeliCapabilities_Final_Update.pdf https://rotorcraft.arc.nasa.gov/Publications/files/HoverStandDevelopment_Final.pdf https://arxiv.org/abs/2511.14934 https://rotorcraft.arc.nasa.gov/Publications/files/1689_Koning_Final_011924.pdf https://rotorcraft.arc.nasa.gov/Publications/files/1.c037023.pdf
Similar Results
Flexible Wing Aircraft with Distributed Flight Control Surfaces
Multi-Objective Flight Control Optimization Framework
Composite materials are being used in aerospace design because of their high strength-to-weight ratio. On modern airplanes, composite wings offer a greater degree of aerodynamic efficiency due to weight savings, but at the same time introduce more structural flexibility than their aluminum counterparts. Under off-design flight conditions, changes in the wing shape due to structural flexibility cause the wing aerodynamics to be non-optimal. This effect could offset any weight saving benefits realized by the composite wings. Structural flexibility could also cause adverse interactions with flight control and structural vibration which can compromise aircraft stability, pilot handling qualities, and passenger ride quality. NASA Ames Research Center has developed a novel technology that employs a new multi-objective flight control optimization framework to achieve multiple control objectives simultaneously. This technology leverages the availability of distributed flight control surfaces in modern transports. The multi-objective flight control technology comprises the following objectives all acting in a synergistic manner: 1) traditional stability augmentation and pilot command-following flight control, 2) drag minimization, 3) aeroelastic mode suppression, 4) gust load alleviation, and 5) maneuver load alleviation. Each of these objectives can be a major control system design in its own right. Thus, the multi-objective flight control technology can effectively manage the complex interactions of the individual single-objective flight control system design and take into account multiple competing requirements to achieve optimal flight control solutions that have the best compromise for these requirements. In addition, a real- time drag minimization control strategy is included in the guidance loop. This feature utilizes system identification methods to estimate aerodynamic parameters for the on-line optimization. The aerodynamic parameters are also used in the multi-objective flight control for drag minimization and maneuver/ gust load alleviation control.
Simple COBRA geometry shape
Co-Optimization of Blunt Body Shapes for Moving Vehicles
Vehicles designed for purposes of exploration of the planets and other atmospheric bodies in the Solar System favor the use of mid-Lift/Drag blunt body geometries. Such shapes can be designed so as to yield favorable hypersonic aerothermodynamic properties for low heating and hypersonic aerodynamic properties for maneuverability and stability. The entry trajectory selected influences entry peak heating and integrated heating loads which in turn influences the design of the thermal protection system. A nominal is used to compare each shape considered. The vehicle will be subject to both launch and entry loading along with structural integrity constraints that may further influence shape design. Further, such vehicles must be sized so as to fit on existing or realizable launch vehicles, often within existing launch payload shroud constraints.
Adaptive wind estimation for small unmanned aerial systems using motion data
The technology presents an on-board estimation, navigation and control architecture for multi-rotor drones flying in an urban environment. It consists of adaptive algorithms to estimate the vehicle's aerodynamic drag coefficients with respect to still air and urban wind components along the flight trajectory, with guaranteed fast and reliable convergence to the true values. Navigation algorithms generate feasible trajectories between given way-points that take into account the estimated wind. Control algorithms track the generated trajectories as long as the vehicle retains a sufficient number of functioning rotors that are capable of compensating for the estimated wind. The technology provides a method of measuring wind profiles on a drone using existing motion sensors, like the inertial measurement unit (IMU), rate gyroscope, etc., that are observably necessary for any drone to operate. The algorithms are used to estimate wind around the drone. They can be used for stability or trajectory calculations, and are adaptable for use with any UAV regardless of the knowledge of weight and inertia. They further provide real-time calculations without additional sensors. The estimation method is implemented using onboard computing power. It rapidly converges to true values, is computationally inexpensive, and does not require any specific hardware or specific vehicle maneuvers for the convergence. All components of this on-board system are computationally effective and are intended for a real time implementation. The method's software is developed in a Matlab/Simulink environment, and has executable versions, which are suitable for majority of existing onboard controllers. The algorithms were tested in simulations.
Passenger Airplane
Real-Time Drag Opti-mization Control Framework
According to the International Air Transport Association statistics, the annual fuel cost for the global airline industry is estimated to be about $140 billion in 2017. Therefore, fuel cost is a major cost driver for the airline industry. Advanced future transport aircraft will likely employ adaptive wing technologies that enable the wings of those aircraft to adaptively reconfigure themselves in optimal shapes for improved aerodynamic efficiency throughout the flight envelope. The need for adaptive wing technologies is driven by the cost of fuel consumption in commercial aviation. NASA Ames has developed a novel way to address aerodynamic inefficiencies experienced during aircraft operation. The real-time drag optimization control method uses an on-board, real-time sensor data gathered from the aircraft conditions and performance during flight (such as engine thrust or wing deflection). The sensor data are inputted into an on-board model estimation and drag optimization system which estimates the aerodynamic model and calculates the optimal settings of the flight control surfaces. As the wings deflect during flight, this technology uses an iterative approach whereby the system continuously updates the optimal solution for the flight control surfaces and iteratively optimizes the wing shape to reduce drag continuously during flight. The new control system for the flight control surfaces can be integrated into an existing flight control system. This new technology can be used on passenger aircraft, cargo aircraft, or high performance supersonic jets to optimize drag, improve aerodynamic efficiency, and increase fuel efficiency during flight. In addition, it does not require a specific aircraft math model which means it does not require customization for different aircraft designs. The system promises both economic and environmental benefits to the aviation industry as less fuel is burned.
Anti-Phase Noise Suppression Rotor Technologies
Rotor noise and vibration are two sources of operational challenges for all aircraft operating with open rotors such as helicopters, unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs), urban air mobility personal air vehicles, drones, and aircraft operating with ducted fans such as passenger aircraft. One disadvantage of convention rotor design is the noise due to noise-induced shed vortices generated by rotor blades. The unique problem with rotor noise and vibration is the periodic blade passage that causes a harmonic reinforcement and causes the rotor blades to vibrate and generate noise sources. This technology from NASA Ames seeks to optimize the implementation of anti-phase trailing edge designs and asymmetric blade tip treatments for rotor noise suppression and integrated aircraft noise solutions by incorporating the anti-phase rotor design concepts into an aircraft flight control system to reduce noise footprint. There are several embodiments of the invention, which include the following: (1) an anti-phase trailing edge design whereby the trailing edge pattern of the leading rotor blade is offset by a phase shift from the trailing edge pattern of the following blade; (2) an anti-phase rotor design implementing asymmetric blade tips with inverted airfoil; and (3) other anti-phase enabled concepts such as unequal blade length, ducted rotors with non-radial unequally spaced struts, and multi-axis tilt rotor design incorporating the anti-phase rotor design.
Stay up to date, follow NASA's Technology Transfer Program on:
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
Facebook Logo X Logo Linkedin Logo Youtube Logo